Tata Punch EV vs MG Comet EV: Which Is the Best Budget Electric Car in India? Check Price And Range

Best Electric Car in India 2026: The competition on Indian roads is no longer just about mileage, but also lightning-fast speed and affordable battery rental plans. The battle between the Tata Punch EV and MG Comet EV has left customers in a quandary. While the Tata Punch EV is known for its 5-star safety and long range, the MG Comet is making its mark in city traffic with its unique design and low price.

Now, both companies have introduced ‘Battery as a Service’ (BaaS) models, making purchasing an electric car as easy as buying a mobile phone. Today we’ll analyze the pricing, charging technology, and speed of these two electric powerhouses in detail to help you make the right choice.

Battery Rental Model (BaaS)

To revolutionize the electric car market, both Tata and MG have introduced battery rental schemes. This means you pay less for the car and rent the battery based on your usage. The Tata Punch EV’s rental cost is ₹2.6 per kilometer, while the MG Comet EV will cost you ₹3.2 per kilometer. If you travel long distances, Tata’s rental plan can save you significantly. The MG Comet may seem cheaper initially with a price tag of ₹5 lakh, but the Punch EV’s lower rental charge makes it more cost-effective in the long run.

Charging Technology

There’s a huge difference between the two cars in terms of charging. The Tata Punch EV supports advanced 65kW DC fast charging, which allows it to charge from 10% to 80% in just 26 minutes. This is an essential feature for highway travel. In contrast, the MG Comet EV lacks DC fast charging. However, its battery is smaller, so it can be charged in just a few hours using a standard home AC charger. The Comet is specifically designed for commuting to and from work within the city, while the Punch EV is also ready for longer trips.

Features and Comfort

In terms of interiors, the MG Comet feels extremely premium despite its compact size. It features a 10.25-inch dual-screen display, giving it the feel of a high-tech gadget. On the other hand, the Punch EV Facelift is equipped with features that are close to the hearts of Indian customers. It offers an electric sunroof, ventilated seats (a boon in summer), and a wireless smartphone charger. While the Comet is best suited for narrow city streets, the Punch EV proves to be more practical due to its tall stance and comfortable cabin.

Safety and Durability

When it comes to safety, the Tata Punch EV is unmatched. It received a 5-star rating in the India NCAP crash test, making it one of the safest cars in the country. The Punch EV offers safety features like six airbags, a 360-degree camera, and a tire pressure monitoring system (TPMS). The MG Comet features all-wheel disc brakes, but lags far behind the Tata in terms of airbags and crash test ratings. Tata is always the preferred choice for customers seeking family safety.

Range and Power Competition

On the performance front, the Tata Punch EV boasts a large 40 kW battery that delivers a tremendous range of 468 km (ARAI) on a single full charge. Its powerful motor provides lightning-fast speed on the roads. In contrast, the MG Comet EV has a range of only 230 km and generates 42 PS of power. The Comet’s objective isn’t speed, but smooth handling and low power consumption.