Gratuity: Employees typically assume that a minimum of five years of service is necessary to qualify for gratuity. However, a notable ruling by the Karnataka High Court has reignited discussions about this criterion. The court directed a gratuity payment of Rs 1.75 lakh to a former Bengaluru Metro employee who served for four years, nine months, and 12 days.

Additionally, the company was ordered to pay 10% annual interest on this sum. The court clarified that eligibility for gratuity should not be judged solely based on the dates of joining and leaving employment but must also account for the actual number of days worked. Let us explore the conditions under which gratuity might be granted before completing five years and the potential implications of this ruling for other employees.

What is the background of the case?

This case concerns a former assistant engineer employed by the Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation (BMRCL). The employee joined the organisation on 6 July 2017 and resigned on 19 March 2022, with his official release from service on 18 April 2022, amounting to a total tenure of 4 years, 9 months, and 12 days. After leaving, he requested gratuity from the company, based on his last monthly salary of Rs 64,210, amounting to approximately Rs 1.85 lakh. The company declined, arguing that the employee had not completed the mandatory five years of service. Consequently, the employee sought legal remedy. The case reached the Karnataka High Court, where the employee contended that he had worked over 240 days in his fifth year, thus qualifying for gratuity.

What was the basis for the High Court’s ruling?

On 26 September 2026, a division bench of the Karnataka High Court allowed the employee’s appeal. The bench, consisting of Justice D.K. Singh and Justice H. Shanti Bhushan, ruled that eligibility for gratuity is not determined merely by completing five calendar years. Instead, it requires assessing the actual number of days worked during the relevant period and considering the legal definitions of continuous service.

The court ordered Bengaluru Metro to pay the employee Rs 1.75 lakh as gratuity, along with 10% annual interest on the amount, effective from 18 May 2022. This ruling clarified that under certain conditions, employees with less than five years of service may qualify for gratuity. However, this does not imply that every employee leaving before five years is automatically entitled to gratuity.

What does the law say about gratuity?

In India, gratuity payments are governed mainly by the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, which aims to provide financial protection to employees for their long-term service.

Section 4(1) of this Act generally requires employees to have completed at least five years of continuous service to be eligible for gratuity. However, this five-year condition does not apply in specific cases such as the employee’s death or disability. Understanding Section 4 alone is insufficient; Section 2A of the Act, which defines continuous service, is also crucial. The importance of this definition was underscored in the Karnataka High Court judgment.

What is the significance of the 240-day rule?

The 240-day rule plays a key role in gratuity regulations. It allows an employee to be considered as having completed one year of continuous service in certain circumstances, even if they have not worked the full 12 months.

In simple terms:

For employees working six days a week:
One year of continuous service is deemed fulfilled if the employee has worked at least 240 days within the relevant 12-month period.

For employees working five days a week:

This means that the actual days worked are taken into account when determining eligibility. The mere difference between joining and leaving dates should not be the only factor. Nonetheless, the 240- or 190-day rule does not automatically waive the five-year requirement in every instance. This must be interpreted in the context of the legal definition of continuous service and the specific circumstances. The Karnataka High Court emphasised this point.

What should be considered when leaving a job before completing five years?

If you are contemplating leaving your job before completing five years with a company, it is helpful to be aware of some important considerations.

1- Keep accurate records of your employment tenure

Simply counting the years and months of employment based on the calendar may not be enough. Also, consider the actual number of days you worked during the relevant period.

2- Maintain attendance and salary records

Company attendance records, salary slips, appointment letters and documents related to leaving the job can be helpful in claiming gratuity in future.

3 Do not consider the company’s refusal as final.

If the company refuses to pay gratuity, citing that you haven’t completed five years, you should definitely check the legal eligibility of your case. You can consult the relevant labor authority or a legal expert.

4 Note the date of leaving the job and the working days

The date of resignation, the date of release from the company, and the number of days worked in the fifth year can be important, so keep all these records safe.

Will all employees benefit from this decision?

This decision is particularly relevant for employees who have served for less than five years and have met the legal requirements for continuous service during the relevant period. However, it is important to note that this High Court decision is based on the facts and legal provisions of a specific case. Therefore, each employee’s eligibility may vary depending on the number of days worked, the nature of the job, the organization, and the applicable law.